Elevate Hospitality

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California

👍 Reviews 📌 Map ℹ️ Information ⏰ Hours

Address: 428 Grotto St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States.
Phone: 7072735012.

Specialties: Deli, Restaurant.
Other points of interest: Delivery, In-store pick-up, Takeaway, Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Credit cards, Free of charge street parking.
Opinions: This company has 32 reviews on Google My Business.
Average opinion: 4.8/5.

📌 Location of The Grotto Eureka

The Grotto Eureka 428 Grotto St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States
☎️7072735012

⏰ Open Hours of The Grotto Eureka

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10 am–3 pm
  • Wednesday: 10 am–3 pm
  • Thursday: 10 am–3 pm
  • Friday: 10 am–3 pm
  • Saturday: 10 am–3 pm
  • Sunday: Closed

The Grotto Eureka is a highly recommended deli and restaurant located at 428 Grotto St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States. This establishment can be contacted by phone at 7072735012. The Grotto Eureka is well-known for its specialties in deli and restaurant offerings. Other points of interest include Delivery, In-store pick-up, Takeaway, Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Credit cards, and Free of charge street parking.

Evaluation and Opinions

This company has earned a solid reputation, with 32 reviews on Google My Business. The average opinion score for The Grotto Eureka is 4.8/5, reflecting its high-quality offerings and exceptional customer service.

Features & Characteristics

  • FANTASTIC sandwiches
  • Warm, welcoming, and accommodating owners and chef
  • A variety of customizable options
  • Knowledgeable staff able to make great customizations
  • Great selection of sandwiches and other offerings
  • Extra horseradish available upon request
  • Full of belly and heart

Summary

The Grotto Eureka is a highly-rated deli and restaurant, offering a variety of customizable options in a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

👍 Reviews of The Grotto Eureka

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Tiger S.
5/5

Sandwiches are FANTASTIC. Don’t let this hole-in-the-wall deceive you, every sandwich item is w o r t h it. The owners and chef are so warm, welcoming and accommodating. Not only do they allow customizations but know how to make the customizations great. Also, they immediately offered to put extra horseradish on my reuben sandwich without me asking, which is a pro move. Bring your hungry self here and you will leave full of belly and heart. Can’t recommend the Grotto enough!

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Soulsista S.
5/5

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ The Grotto = Sandwich Heaven!

Okay, WOW. The Grotto seriously blew me away. I’m talkin’ Gordon Ramsay–approved level of sandwich greatness. 👨‍🍳🔥

I tried the Turkey Pesto, Pastrami Reuben, and the French Dip — and every bite was chef’s kiss. Perfect balance of meat, veggies, and flavor. Nothing soggy, nothing dry — just flavorful perfection stacked between bread.

The vibe? Super friendly, chill, and welcoming — you feel like a regular even if it’s your first time.
Customer service? Phenomenal.
And to top it off, they hooked me up for my birthday! 💕 That extra love made it even more special.

I’m officially hooked. 5 stars isn’t enough — run, don’t walk to The Grotto!

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Halle S.
5/5

From the food to the service to the music playing in the background (yes, even the playlist was 🔥), The Grotto understood the assignment.

The energy was warm, welcoming, and full of flavor. You can tell everything is made with care — fresh, balanced, and delicious. 😮‍💨

Customer service? Impeccable. They even made my birthday feel extra special! 🫶🏽

A whole vibe from start to finish. Highly recommend!

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Jess B.
5/5

I was very happy I stumbled into this place. As soon as i walked in i was hit with a pleasant aroma of fresh baked bread inside. The service was excellent and the sandwiches were massive and delicious. Thank you so much!

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Summer H.
5/5

If you haven't been to The Grotto lately, you're missing out on some seriously good eats. This local gem is serving up the best sandwiches in town.

I got Carrie's Italian Sub and it was DELISH. They have a super cute sandwich nook perfect for people watching out the window.

Seems like they always have fresh bread and slice their meats/cheeses/veggies daily by using this super old school slicer. I haven't seen any other sandwich spots around town that freshly slice their ingredients like The Grotto does!

I hear there are new owners and they're doing an amazing job at bringing this place back to life and providing great service. It's close to my work so consider this my new lunch spot!

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Alita S.
5/5

Very good place, delicious food, and welcoming people. You have the option of building your own sandwich/wrap as well👌

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Alexandrea K.
5/5

Fantastic service, pricing, atmosphere, & quality! There’s a lot of steep competition in the sandwich department but this is by far the best sandwich shop in town. 12/10!!!

The Grotto Eureka - Eureka, California
Jasmin T.
5/5

Great service, great Sammy, great options, fast service, great location. New owners a lovely people. What more can I say? 10/10 recommend.

Go up