Sammy's BBQ & Catering - Eureka, California

Introduction to Sammy’s BBQ & Catering

Sammy’s BBQ & Catering stands as a highly-regarded establishment in Eureka, California, renowned for its authentic barbecue cuisine and comprehensive catering services. Located at 1709 5th St, Eureka, CA 95501, this restaurant and catering company has garnered a significant following due to its commitment to quality, service, and a welcoming atmosphere. With a phone number of 7074434227 and a website at sammysbbqcatering.com, Sammy’s BBQ & Catering is easily accessible and offers a seamless experience for both dine-in and catering customers.

Specialties and Menu Highlights

At its core, Sammy’s BBQ & Catering operates as a dedicated barbecue restaurant, specializing in slow-smoked meats prepared with traditional techniques and time-honored recipes. Their barbecue area is the heart of the operation, where the tantalizing aromas of ribs, brisket, pulled pork, and tri-tip fill the air. The menu boasts an impressive selection of barbecue staples, complemented by a range of side dishes and desserts designed to enhance the overall dining experience. Specifically, the tri-tip is consistently praised for its exceptional flavor and perfectly cooked texture – a testament to the chef's skill and dedication. Furthermore, their signature barbecue sauce is a key component of their success, described by many as ‘deadly good’ and a crucial element in elevating the taste of every dish. Beyond the main meats, guests can explore smaller plates, perfect for sharing, and a selection of desserts to satisfy their sweet tooth.

Location and Accessibility

Sammy’s BBQ & Catering’s location in Eureka provides convenient access for both locals and visitors. Situated at 1709 5th St, the restaurant is readily identifiable and easily reachable. The business offers a variety of options to cater to different needs and preferences, including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in services. Parking is readily available, with both free of charge street parking and a free parking lot conveniently located nearby. Accessibility is a priority, with features such as a wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible toilet ensuring that everyone can enjoy the experience. Furthermore, the restaurant caters to a diverse clientele, accommodating solo dining, groups, tourists, and university students.

Services and Amenities

Sammy’s BBQ & Catering provides a comprehensive range of services designed to meet a wide array of customer needs. The restaurant operates with fast service, ensuring a prompt and efficient dining experience. Reservations are accepted, allowing customers to plan their visits in advance. Payment options are flexible, accepting credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. The establishment is equipped to handle large events, offering professional catering services for corporate gatherings, private parties, and other special occasions. The space is designed to appeal to various demographics, including families with high chairs and kids' menus, as well as those seeking a casual and trendy atmosphere. Free of charge street parking and a free parking lot contribute to a hassle-free visit. Alcohol, beer, and coffee are also available, adding to the overall dining experience. The establishment also fosters a welcoming environment for comfort food lovers, and those looking for a quick and satisfying quick bite.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

Sammy’s BBQ & Catering has consistently received positive feedback from its customers. Currently, the company boasts 400 reviews on Google My Business, reflecting a strong and engaged customer base. The average opinion is 4.3/5, highlighting the overall satisfaction with the restaurant’s food, service, and atmosphere. Comments frequently mention the friendly and helpful staff, the cleanliness of the establishment, and the delicious quality of the barbecue. Many customers express a fondness for the ‘hometown feel’ of the restaurant and its ability to accommodate families. The positive reviews consistently emphasize the exceptional quality of the tri-tip and the restaurant’s signature barbecue sauce. Overall, Sammy’s BBQ & Catering has cultivated a strong reputation as a reliable and enjoyable dining destination.

Contact Information and Website

Address: 1709 5th St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States
Phone: 7074434227
Website: sammysbbqcatering.com

👍 Reviews of Sammy's BBQ & Catering

Sean S.

5/5

Came through here right now on a road trip. This place was recommended by the locals so I had high expectations. Every one of my expectations were met and the bar has been raised. This place is SLAPPING!!

The tri tip is FIRE and the sauce is deadly good. This place is doing it all right. I love the hometown feel in here too. Lots of space being your family. If your stopping by or haven’t tried it yet your missing out.

Also the staff here is super nice and the joint is clean!

Paul C.

5/5

Sammy's BBQ helped us so much! We needed catering for our wedding! Not only was Sammy's affordable they offered incredible service and great food. Our guests loved it so much we took them to the restaurant two days later. Overall excellent food excellent service and really made our dinner special.

Jolian K.

1/5

Went there with colleagues after work today. Ordered the "loaded" kalua pork fries and a pint of cider. The first indication there was a problem was when the server rang up the drink for $7. "I thought it was happy hour," I told her. "Oh, well, the cider is... different," she said, without elaborating. I pointed to the banner hanging prominently under the counter. "It says right here, Happy Hour, 4-6 PM, draft beer and cider $4," I replied. It was 4:30. She seemed flustered, but revised the check to reflect the advertised price.

We then took our seat. The inside of the restaurant was chilly (ambient temperature or less, low 50s), and I regretted not putting on a third layer.

Our food was ready in about 10-15 minutes. I was immediately disappointed when I saw the tiny portion. Imagine a small-sized fast food style paper french fry basket, like in-n-out. Then picture it being filled less than 1/2 way to the top, a literal handful of fries topped with a few specks of indeterminable grey substance. At least there was a drizzle of some kind of sauce on top (I'd asked for ranch but didn't recognize it as such).

The fries were edible, the few of them that there were. The pork was cold, like gobs of congealed fat, flavorless and lacking any semblance of texture. It reminded me of what I'd expect to find at a school cafeteria, except even then the portion size would be at least enough to last more than a couple of bitefuls.

There's a number of decent BBQ places in Eureka. Sammy's unfortunately is not one of them. If you do still think of dining here, be on high alert for bait-and-switch pricing.

David J.

5/5

Amazing food and super friendly staff! The meat is mouth watering! I love their coleslaw. If I lived in the area I would be regular.

Robert M.

5/5

Upon our arrival we were greeted by a very friendly cashier. She helped us figure out our order and made us feel like we were visiting with family. Our food was brought to the table and it was hot and delicious!

Nataki A.

5/5

It’s been a few years since I ate here, but let me tell you!! It’s only gotten better.
First thing that came to mind after my first bite was “make you wanna slap yo momma!!”
Shoutout to auntie for the most delicious cake!!

DANIELLE S.

5/5

Normally, I absolutely love the Crab Cheese Puffs. This day, not so much. They were flavorless, had little filling, and the texture was very different. Nothing has changed, so they said, but I beg to differ...
Hope it's back to normal next time.

william G.

5/5

I got some pork Kahlua to go. It was pretty good. Maybe a little on the southeast side, but the house dressing was a nice combination with it. It was delicious. Worked out very well. Good service kind people.