Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard - Middlebury, Connecticut

👍 Reviews 📌 Map ℹ️ Information ⏰ Hours

Address: 900 Straits Turnpike, Middlebury, CT 06762.
Phone: 2037582888.
Website: ritasice.com
Specialties: Ice cream shop, Dessert restaurant, Dessert shop.
Other points of interest: Small business, Delivery, In-store pickup, In-store shopping, Takeout, Dine-in, Same-day delivery, Solo dining, Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Assistive hearing loop, Seating, Casual, Trending, Family-friendly, Groups, Quick visit, Credit cards, Debit cards, Good for kids, Free parking lot, Free street parking.
Opinions: This company has 151 reviews on Google My Business.
Average opinion: 4.3/5.

📌 Location of Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

☎️2037582888

⏰ Open Hours of Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Monday: 1:30–9 PM
Tuesday: 1:30–9 PM
Wednesday: 1:30–9 PM
Thursday: 1:30–9 PM
Friday: 1:30–9 PM
Saturday: 1:30–9 PM
Sunday: 1:30–9 PM

Okay, here’s a detailed description of Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard, presented in a formal and helpful tone, formatted with

👍 Reviews of Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard - Middlebury, Connecticut

Lauren L.

1/5

Apparently free Italian ices today but they do not have any signs that say that. In fact there was a hand written sign that said first day of spring there is a $2 up charge for custard - weird. Also the flavors were not good, no cream flavored ices. Seats up on half the store.

Hiding the special, did not tell us when we were in the store as if they were trying to hide the special. The two store owners were right there just standing there plus a store employee.

Also agree we’re stingy on the custard. Probably will not return to this Rita’s.

Robert F.

5/5

They have great custard. I love grabbing Rita's when ever I am in town. Looking forward to next time. Thanks !

ppo190

1/5

$9 for the tiniest amount of custard on top and almost none in the bottom? Basically a scam. I’ve been to many of these chains and this portion is a joke.

OFNR S.

5/5

What a great little spot for tasty ice cold treats. Reasonae prices and delicious choices make this a nice goto for the family. Get the frozen custard or an Italian ice. Either way you really can't go wrong.

Crust

1/5

Drove about half an hour to go here and arrived at 9:20, only to find the doors locked forty minutes before they should be, and an uncaring employee that didn't even acknowledge us while being in their line of sight. If you're gonna close at 9 or something, that's completely fine, but make sure that's what your hours actually say, so you don't waste people's time and gas.

Natallia O.

1/5

We just spent $15 plus tip for 2 very tiny ice creams. The portions were unbelievably small. This Rita’s store is very expensive and not worth the money what we paid for.
I am also questioning some health regulations.
There was a dog inside the store, very cute little puppy, but it’s completely wrong.
Also I ordered a waffle cone- the girl sold it to me without any wrapping paper or napkins, she just held the cone with her bare hand, touching the register before and after . I didn’t feel like these employee was trained well.

Raymond S.

1/5

Multiple visits and each one just doesn’t turn out to be good. The ice cream seem to not be par with the texture. Somehow it was off compared to all Rita’s around the area. And the pricing how am I paying 14$ for two vanillas cones up at Bristol but here I’m almost paying 20$ does not make sense.

Victor A.

1/5

Store says they’re open noon to 9pm on Sundays but was clearly closed with nobody inside. Waste of time.