New York Pizza - Hartwell, Georgia

Clark F.

We we're camping near Hartwell GA last week. After a full day of hiking, the boys decided that they would like a pizza. Those teenage boys said, "This is the best pizza they have ever had in their life."
Wow!
This is the Chicago style pizza

Service was perfect also. Dining in is the way to enjoy

Vincent O.

When I first arrived, there was no one there. Open sign was on, but the entry door was locked and no one inside. They were out of some ingredients… (Cheese was one of them) so the owner went to the store to get some. It took a while after I ordered it but OMG it was worth the wait! This place is 5 min from my and I will definitely be going back! I got the Sicilian style pizza, it’s a square pie, and gets cut that way. I got it with extra sauce and extra pepperoni. I just ate two smaller slices and it filled me up! It tastes like “I want more”. It was a huge and “HEAVY” pizza. I’m sure 6 people would have a tough time finishing it off. I finally found a pizza place to call my own. I’m done with eating sub-par pizzas, if you want the best pizza-pie you ever had in your entire life, go try New York Pizza in Hartwell. Give em a call ahead if you’re in a hurry to eat like I was. Otherwise, be prepared for a bit of a wait…but like I said well worth it!!!

Heather S.

We ordered ham sliders as an appetizer. They were fan tastic there was so much cheese and flavor built-in to them. We loved them. We then ordered a stuffed New York pizza and a order of stuffed shells. That pizza was phenomenal. It was probably one of the best pizzas I have ever ate in my life, the stuffed shells were OK. They were not my favorite and seem to be liking a little bit of flavor. However, I would eat that pizza every day the rest of my life easily. The lady at the front desk was super nice service was a little slow, but I feel like the girl was new.

James T.

I love this place if you want a slice they don't have some old cheese pizza laying around and they do you a slice they actually stretch a piece of dough into a triangle like a slice of pizza put all the toppings on it and bake it fresh it's almost getting like your own little mini Slice Pizza this is incredible what an idea fresh slice of pizza anytime I need a slice I go there

Linda L.

We got the Super Combo Pizza. And Meatball Sub. And Garlic Knots. I love the atmosphere And the Receptionist, Waitress was very nice. The food was awesome.. The Cooks really know how to make the best pizza

gwen H.

Repeated mistakes of not getting my order correct for take out. Would not refund moneyfor a large pizza special ($26) they made wrong, but suggested to refund a topping ($2 fee) for the ingredient they left off which messed up my
order. Bad for business, unfair and overall I'm unsatisfied. I paid $27 for a speciality pizza they messed up and their solution was to refund the amount of the ingredient ($2)they left off. Smh. I won't be patronizing this establishment.

Holly W.

Amazing food and great people. So happy they are still opened in Hartwell. Since they closed in Anderson I sure have missed the food. If you haven't tried them I highly recommend you do it will not disappoint 👌👌👌💕

Emily M.

Delicious pizza! This was our first time trying this place and we ordered the veggie pizza and the Chicago deep-dish style pizza. Both were top-notch and very much enjoyed.👌 The pies had a great flavor. The staff were also very friendly and helpful. We will be back!