New Jersey Pizza Co - Flagstaff, Arizona

Evan L.

No idea how this place has 4.5 stars. Got 2 pizzas and a salad. Opened up the pizza when I got home and it was just a pile of grease. One bite and tossed it. Honestly feel like I got scammed for paying $70 for mostly grease. So incredibly pissed off. Also ordered ranch.. didn’t get any., no silverwear for the salad, and wrote no olives on the salad and guess what, we got olives . I get it’s a Saturday night but I feel personally attacked after paying as much as I did. Side note, the salad was decent but obviously not why I ordered from a pizza joint. Do not fall for the 4.5 stars on Google, this place is trash and they clearly don’t care about the customer.

Mitchell Z.

I would like to take a minute to give a shout out to this incredible pizza place and staff. We came in after a playoff game for youth football with over 40 people. Not only did they make us feel welcome but they handled our chaos and our family like their own. We order pizzas, wings, and cheese bread which all was delicious. They handled their regular busy customer base while not skipping a beat to get started for us as well. Thank you for making our special night a memorable one! We will certainly be back when we are in town again.

Bryan B.

You will not find a better pizza in Flagstaff. Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Also, if you not had pepperoni and fresh jalapeños, you’re missing out.

G F.

Friendly folks for sure! Definitely artists at their craft. The pizza was DELICIOUS, but INSANELY greasy. Especially the cheese. I loved the Nate! Absolutely great flavors, unique combinations, the crust is beautifully crispy but HOLY CRAP THE GREASE. After padding it with some paper towels, it is one of the best pizzas I've had in Flagstaff

Abi R.

We decided to try out a new pizza place and were shockingly disappointed. Delivery took 2 hours. Kitchens get busy, so a long wait can be excused as long as the end result is a delicious meal. This was far from it. We each tried a slice and the rest was tossed into the trash. The pizza was so greasy, that when held upright, it dripped onto the plate. Flavor-wise it was very bland and oddly tasted watered down. Maybe their other styles would have been a better choice. We also ordered wings. Thankfully, they were edible. Not great, but edible. They were very dry and tough.

Glenn H.

A Perfect Wedding Anniversary Spot – 10/10 Would Recommend!

My wife and I decided to celebrate our wedding anniversary at New Jersey Pizza Company in Flagstaff, Arizona, and it was one of the best decisions we’ve ever made. We specifically chose this place after hearing great things, and it truly lived up to the hype!

From the moment we walked in, we could feel the passion and commitment the owner has for this place. The story behind the restaurant was touching, and you can tell the heart and soul that goes into everything they do. The food? Absolutely incredible. The pizza and wings were some of the best we’ve ever had. Every bite was full of flavor, and you could tell the ingredients were top-notch. We were so impressed we left a heavy tip—partly because we were in love with the food, but also because we were in awe of the dedication and love the owner pours into this business.

Ten out of ten, we would highly recommend this spot to anyone. Honestly, if I could, I’d give them a Michelin star! LOL. This place is a must-visit, and we can’t wait to come back for another memorable meal.

Thank you, New Jersey Pizza Company, for making our anniversary so special!

Jonathan B.

Had really high expectations from all the different reviews. Ended being highly disappointed. Almost an hour wait for food even though only 1 other customer was in there and 2 pickup orders came in. They messed up our order even though there were only 3 toppings between 2 pizzas. Pizza ended up just being ok, crust was burnt. Salad was decent. Definitely wanted more for the price of pizzas ($19 fo 12 inch pizza).

Vallie

Very welcoming staff and was our first time trying this place out. Got a large calzone with fire roasted chilies, pepperoni, and Sicilian spicy sausage. It was delicious! Definitely holds the flavor of pizza and calzones from back East.