Nancy's Cafe - Park Hill, Oklahoma

Nancy's Cafe

Nancy's Cafe is a delightful restaurant located at 26380 S Indian Rd, Park Hill, OK 74451, United States. It offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere for diners seeking great coffee, comfort food, and healthy options. With a focus on both quick bites and more substantial meals, the cafe caters to a variety of tastes and preferences.

Specialties

• Great coffee
• Desserts
• Lunch and dinner options
• Small plates
• Catering services

Other Points of Interest

• Outdoor seating
• Takeaway
• Dine-in
• Delivery
• Wheelchair accessibility
• Great tea selection
• Solo dining
• Casual and cozy ambience
• Trendy and inviting decor
• Friendly to tourists
• Accepts credit cards
• Family-friendly
• Free parking available

The cafe is particularly well-known for its delicious pies, made with love by the owner, Nancy. Customers often praise the excellent service and the welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Many have described Nancy as the grandmother they wish they had, showcasing the warmth and comfort that the cafe exudes.

Opinions and Reviews

Nancy's Cafe boasts an impressive number of reviews on Google My Business, with a staggering 127 reviews. The cafe has garnered a remarkable average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars, indicating a high level of customer satisfaction. Reviewers frequently mention the exceptional quality of the food, particularly the pies, as well as the outstanding service provided by the staff.

One review stands out, describing the cafe as 'a cool spot' where 'Nancy is simply the grandmother you wish you had.' The reviewer also praises the excellent service and the delicious pies, expressing their excitement to return for lunch. This review encapsulates the essence of Nancy's Cafe – a hidden gem that offers a comforting atmosphere, delectable food, and exceptional service.

With its great location, ample parking, and commitment to providing a delightful dining experience, Nancy's Cafe is a must-visit for anyone in the Park Hill area. Whether you're in the mood for a quick coffee, a hearty meal, or a slice of heavenly pie, Nancy's Cafe has something to offer.

👍 Reviews of Nancy's Cafe

C C.

5/5

What a cool spot! Nancy is simply the grandmother you wish you had. Her pies are simply 😘👌 delicious 😋 The service is excellent and I cannot wait to come back for lunch. This is a gem if you're in the area!

Kendra M.

3/5

The pie and the service were good, but the sandwich was very average and the pasta salad okay, but under seasoned. The potato soup was great. There was nothing particularly wrong with the sandwich (although the sourdough was a little stale/dry), but just super blah overall. More craveable sandwich combinations (avocado spread, whole mustard seed spread, etc.) and the choice for toasted sandwiches with better quality bread would definitely be an improvement.

Ryan S.

5/5

We go mainly for dessert. Nancy's coconut cream pie is divine! Her chocolate cake is wonderful! Don't keep saying, "I need to try it." Go get you some. You won't be disappointed.

Claire W.

5/5

Best pie I have ever eaten. The servers were kind and Mrs. Nancy was there telling stories about her family and how she learned to cook. Only downside about the whole restaurant is that I can’t sit there forever and only eat that pie. I would if I could. The sandwich combo was good and the special options look amazing.

Billie M.

5/5

We LOVE Nancy's. Great food, fabulous desserts. They have a server, maybe early to mid 60's who is one of the nicest ladies in Tahlequah. She makes a good experience even better. My wife and I drive 15 miles one-way to eat there at least once per week at lunch.

Victoria S.

5/5

Nancy's Cafe is a Treasure in the Town of Keys OK. The Restaurant is located close to Lake Tenkiller. Nancy's Chicken Salad Sandwiches are Delicious she makes them with SHREDDED Chicken Breast, Grapes.. etc and the Sandwich is big enough for two Adults to share! She also makes Soups! Yum! Mx. Nancy also has many Delicious PIES including Chocolate, coconut cream, and Pecan. She has a melt-in-ypur-mputh Chocolate Cake. Everything is so good and made Fresh. The people should work there are very Friendly and Helpful.

Lucretia F.

5/5

The food was awesome, I got the Saturday lunch special and a slice of lemon pie, it was all homemade and delicious. This Arkansas girl will be back

Allison B.

5/5

The pecan pie we ordered for Thanksgiving was delicious!