Modo Mio Italian Restaurant - McAlester, Oklahoma

Andrea P.

I had a to go order. I travel quite a bit and try a lot of food. I was looking forward to some Italian food. They were out of fried ravioli as an appetizer. That was a bummer but they offered fried cheese sticks. They were not good. I ate some of those because that was my meal and the bread. The bread was good. That's why I gave 2 stars because the bread and marinara sauce were quite good. The lasagna was a huge disappointment though. The cheese sticks I didn't have high hopes for so I wasn't disappointmented. The lasagna was inedible. There was zero flavor, most noodles were burned or rubbery. It didn't even look like any lasagna I've ever had. Maybe it was an off night but I will not go back there. I have to have a receipt for my work and it was weird asking for one. I paid when I picked up my food and they just took off. I saw an eye roll, but maybe that was to the door dash guy....I can not say it was to me for sure.

Macy S.

My fiance and I love this place. The food is amazing. The setup of the restaurant is beautiful. Love their decor. The rolls are the best! I do not recommend the house salad dressing for the salads that come with the meals. I asked for Italian and they offered me "house or vinaigrette" and I did not like the house dressing at all. We ordered the spaghetti works and the baked ziti. Portions were amazing and food was delicious. We will be back.

Dione ?. V.

Atmosphere was ok, we went for lunch or a little after lunch and were the only ones there.

My spaghetti was very bland and the meatballs had this weird mushy texture.

My husband said his lasagna was a 9 out of 10.

Tini S.

The food was great! I had calzone with pepperoni and it was wonderful. My husband had the sausage and peppers parmigiana and thought it was also wonderful. We both had salads and both enjoyed those. He got house dressing and thought it was delicious. The garlic knots were so good. They serve them with some butter on but not loaded and give you butter to add if you want. I like extra butter my husband does not so that was a win win also. Will definitely come back when traveling through and highly recommend! Nothing negative to say at all. Staff was great! Loved the music selections

Tommy S.

Wife and I stopped in for dinner. I was wanting pizza BUT the special was ribeye steak in Marsala and Mushrooms so I was all for that!
Steak cooked as requested and the Marsala and mushrooms was amazing. Loved it. Wife stated her shrimp fettuccini was great also. Came with dinner salad and rolls. My steak also came with veggies or spaghetti son had a spicy marinara.
Highly recommend! Great service and price also.

Travlin N. (.

Service: excellent 👌🏻👍🏻

Food: good. Taste very homemade. Rolls, excellent 👌🏻👍🏻

Atmosphere: fantastic 🤩 the restaurant is beautiful.

The service was definitely amazing. Our server was professional, prompt, friendly, and helpful! Thank you!

The restaurant is beautifully decorated! There are many paintings on the wall with Italy as the main theme, I guess. The lighting was warm and we can see the food clearly. We had a good time!

James P.

To my surprise- the wonderful restaurant has been in business for 5+ years. Food was homemade - Ravioli was perfect balance of dough and filling. Marinara tasted like sauces in Italy. Not over seasoned but full of flavors. Definitely fresh and would recommend for a great BYOB and quiet relaxing meal with outstanding service.

Mary J. H.

We had been there to eat a few years ago and loved it. Buy I wish we had gone to Freddy's. The Lasagna was extremely small and not really enough for a meal. My Eggplant Parm was terrible! It tasted like I was chewing on a sponge, dark brown and chewy. Only thing worth eating was the pasta and the roll. I'm surprised your still in business putting out food this quality.