Lake Martin Pizza Co. - Dadeville, Alabama

Shelby Andrist

Although the atmosphere of the restaurant was great, the pizza itself was maybe a 2.5...super dry (not enough marinara) and although it was dark on the bottom, the crust hadn't been fully cooked through.

We would have purchased dessert if they had it available, but after having the pizza, I'm glad we didn't.

We added the Parm you see here, but got a build your own with sausage, bacon, and green peppers. It's clear they don't homemaker their sausage (it's the freezer stuff) and we were really unsatisfied.

Melissa Hyche

Embarrassed that we brought out of town guests here. Their process is terrible. If you are dining in you shouldn’t get behind all of the call in orders. Something is off with that system. We were told 1.5 hour wait on our pizza we said okay. After nearly 2 hours we were ready to go home and asked for a refund the owner was not accommodating and said too bad for your wait it’s Labor Day weekend. We finally took the pizza home. It’s DEFINITELY NOT worth a 2 hour wait. Don’t waste a whole evening on this place. The pizza is not that great and not worth the total frustration.

Susan Freeman

Tonight I ordered my pizza by phone at 6:34 pm. I was told it would be 40-45 minutes for pickup. No problem . I am a little bit of a drive to the Blue Creek location so we left out for the drive taking our time. I arrived at 7:04 pm and we sat in the car until around 7:14 pm at which time I went in and the girl at the register said it would be another 15 minutes. I paid for our pizza (my first mistake and included a tip). I went back to my SUV and waited until 7:35 pm and went back in. She said it was about to come out so I went to end of the counter to wait. The guy cutting and boxing asked my name and I told him. He looked like a “deer in headlights”. I knew immediately something was wrong. He began looking for a ticket. The lady helping him went to the front to ask and came back and told me that my pizza had not been made and it would be another 8-10 minutes!! All this not to mention it’s only about 110 degrees inside this place! After waiting 1 hour and 20 minutes to have the pizza in my hands, I actually got home at 8:30 pm to eat…?. LAST TRIP TO LAKE MARTIN PIZZA…wish I could get my $29.22

Joni Ahlers

Went here based on a local recommendation! Glad we went! The outside patio looks amazing, a little too chilly for us so we dined inside! The staff was super friendly! We ordered a Hawaiian and a cheese w pepperoni and banana peppers! It was delicious, the sauce was great the pizza was cooked to perfection! The table behind us had ordered the dill pickle pizza and when I say the locals are friendly I mean it! They overheard us talking about the sill pickle pizza and offered us a piece to try! OMG if you go to LMP you must get the dill pickle pizza! It’s the perfect amount of garlic and pickles enough to make your tastebuds go pickle crazy! We were so hungry we forgot to snap photos of the pizza itself but it’s definitely a must try if you are near by!

Chuck Johnson

Ordered 3 large pizzas to go, told 1 hour and 30 minutes. No problem, head to the bar. No bartender. Once again, no problem, purchased a couple of adult beverages inside. Waited an hour and a half and watched customers who came in 30 minutes after us get their pizzas. Walked in for an update and they hadn't started the order. I asked to have my order canceled, was told to go stand in line. This is what happens when you pay up front. Not one employee in this place cared about taking care of my order. I actually tipped when I paid. Last time I will darken the door of this place. Walked out with no food.

Brian Sneed

I would give it lower if I could. We called in an order and was told 45 minutes. I drove 20 minutes to pick up and they didn’t have the pizza. The cashier remembered taking the order but the ticket did not print. We will make you one that will take 35 minutes. But that was going to be real fast. They could not have cared less. No thank you not ever again!

TMP 826

The pizza here at Lake Martin Pizza Co. is SOLID! Their cheese pizza showcases everything done right in making the perfect NY style pizza. The pizza is baked with a perfect crisp bottom crust and a soft, flavorful edge crust. The pickle pizza was a surprise delight and would recommend!

Lauren Wilkerson

The food is fantastic when they actually have it. This is now at least the 4th time I have called to make a pick up order and I show up to find out they don't actually have what I ordered. The very first question I asked when I called is do you guys have garlic knots this evening (they are popular so they are frequently out and would decide whether or not we would be eating from here). The guy responded we have a few, I asked for clarification on what a few meant. He said we have a few orders of them. So I responded with I would like an order of 1 dozen, and gave them the rest of my order. I was instructed that our order would be ready in 30 to 35 mins. When we arrived to pick up my order they said they were out of garlic knots. Upset is an understatement. I would've chosen a different restaurant to eat at had they been upfront that they were out and the fact they didn't even call to let us know is even worse. Probably won't be back seeing as this is a regular occurrence.