Emelio's Restaurant - Columbus, Ohio

Dan P.

Good tavern style pizza and overall, it was a solid choice. The crust was a definite highlight – flavorful and crispy, clearly a point of pride. And they certainly didn't skimp on the toppings, which were plentiful and well-distributed. However, the cheese, while melted well, lacked that fresh, vibrant taste I was hoping for. It tasted a bit processed. Despite that, the quality of the crust and toppings made it a very enjoyable tavern-style pizza. If they could improve the cheese, it would be a real winner. I'd definitely order it again, especially if you love a good, loaded tavern-style pie."

Joshua F.

My new favorite Columbus Pizza, this chill bar has great prices and great tavern pizza. The char of exterior bites are spectacular and the crispy peperoni is beautiful. Both halves were fantastic, this pie was so much fun to eat and there’s a great local vibe with lots of tvs for sports too. Good space, nice and clean inside, and friendly staff make this bar super chill.

Carter D.

I stopped here on a Saturday evening around 6:30. It was busy but we were still able to get a table. The server was quick and our pizzas arrived a little less than 20 minutes after ordering. This is a very good thin crust pizzas.

The area is a little rough but the pizza makes up for it. I would consider this to be above average.

carterpuma

This is in a rough area with bad traffic but the pizza was really good. The guy who answered the phone and checked me out was also very pleasant.

Brianne H.

I'm devastated to write this review. Emilio's has been a long time favorite of mine. I have historically been obsessed with their special salad. Today we called to place a delivery order and the person who was taking the order was saying it would be at least an hour for delivery. To which we advised totally fine no rush and the person taking the order was clearly not thrilled we were still willing to place the order it caused us to overall feel like we should just not order because he clearly didn't want to be inconvenienced by this.
Honestly im sad this has been my favorite pizza since moving to the area and I can't say anything bad about the food or its quality but im hoping they can resolve the customer service because it will be missed in our household until then.

John A.

I've only found out about Emelio's recently due to the Portnoy video and as a lover of pizza had to try it out- while I've yet to have time to check out the restaurant- the pizza is phenomenal. To start, the prices are extremely reasonable for not only what you get, but the quality. Above and beyond some of the bigger names in the city who've gradually increased their prices over the years.. outside of that in the 7+ times I've been, the staff is always beyond polite, especially the last time I went in I had an issue with an order and Addison went above and beyond to correct the issue. If you live in Columbus or are visiting, get a pie from Emelio's.

Myra W.

A decent thin and crispy pizza. The perfect amount of sauce and cheese with generous toppings. I’m not a fan of thin and crispy but I did enjoy this flavorful pie. Don’t be put off by the interior - not fancy. There is a huge bar with some booths. I think there is another room for larger groups. Very clean bathroom. I have heard that the salad and subs are terrific. Definitely check it out.

Renee W.

I had the best experience working with Emelio's Catering for my wedding! I worked with Haifa to help plan everything. She always responded quickly and it was obvious she genuinely cared about delivering great service. I received several compliments regarding the food and service they provided from guests - the appetizers were especially a huge hit! During the wedding, the staff was super friendly and continuously made sure my husband and I had everything we wanted. This is by far one of the easiest vendors I have worked with - everything went flawlessly. I highly recommend them!