Eatly - Urbana, Ohio

Eatly: A Culinary Destination in Urbana, Ohio

For those seeking an authentic and delightful Italian dining experience, Eatly stands as a premier choice in Urbana, Ohio. Located at 116 Miami St, Urbana, OH 43078, this restaurant has rapidly gained recognition for its exceptional food, warm atmosphere, and commitment to customer satisfaction. With a dedicated phone line at 9374503337, patrons can easily make reservations or inquiries. The restaurant’s website, currently under development, will provide further details and updates in the near future.

Specialties and Culinary Offerings

Eatly specializes in Italian cuisine, presenting a comprehensive menu that caters to a wide range of palates. The restaurant is particularly renowned for its handcrafted pizzas, including the popular Tuscan pizza, often cited by customers as a standout dish. Beyond pizza, the menu boasts a selection of classic Italian pasta dishes, hearty meat entrees, and delectable seafood options. The restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients is evident in every bite, creating a truly immersive culinary journey.

Key Features and Amenities

Eatly offers a welcoming and comfortable setting for diners of all types. The restaurant features outdoor seating, allowing guests to enjoy their meals al fresco during pleasant weather. Dine-in service is readily available, creating a traditional and convivial dining experience. For those unable to dine in, delivery services are also provided, expanding the restaurant's reach to surrounding areas.

• Great Dessert Selection: Patrons consistently praise the restaurant’s desserts, with the ‘pineapple’ and ‘chocolate dream’ frequently mentioned as exceptional choices.
• Extensive Wine List: Eatly boasts a carefully curated wine list, offering a diverse selection to complement the menu’s offerings.
• Variety of Meal Options: The restaurant caters to various dining needs, offering lunch and dinner service, as well as a delightful brunch menu.
• Accessibility: Eatly is designed to be inclusive, offering wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible parking lot, and wheelchair accessible seating.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

Eatly has garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback from its patrons, consistently earning a 4.8/5 average opinion on Google My Business. With over 110 reviews, the restaurant’s online reputation reflects its dedication to quality and service. Customers frequently commend the restaurant’s friendly staff, delicious food, and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant’s transition to Urbana has been met with enthusiasm, with many noting the continued excellence of the food. Dishes like the lasagna and scramble eggs with steak have become particular favorites, contributing to the restaurant's growing popularity. The “Marana and meatballs” combination is also a frequently enjoyed selection.

Additional Points of Interest

Beyond its core offerings, Eatly provides a range of features designed to enhance the dining experience. The restaurant features a bar onsite, offering a selection of beverages and a casual atmosphere. Comfort food reigns supreme, appealing to those seeking familiar and satisfying flavors. A selection of small plates is available, perfect for sharing and sampling a variety of dishes. The restaurant also caters to solo dining, groups, and tourists, ensuring a comfortable experience for all. Credit cards are accepted, and reservations are welcome. The restaurant is described as casual, cozy, trendy, and offers a restroom for guests’ convenience.

In essence, Eatly represents a delightful addition to Urbana's culinary landscape. Its commitment to authentic Italian cuisine, combined with its welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, makes it a destination well worth visiting. Whether you’re craving a classic pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or simply a delicious dessert, Eatly promises a memorable dining experience. The restaurant's continued success is a testament to its dedication to quality and customer satisfaction.

👍 Reviews of Eatly

Scott M.

5/5

First time here, food was very good. Service was great.
I got the Tuscan pizza, also had the pineapple dessert.
Wife and daughter shared the Marana and meatballs, with the chocolate dream and lemon with black raspberry.

Now that they have moved to Urbana, the food is just as good. Got the lasagna which was incredible, wife and daughter shared the scramble eggs and steak.

Lori

5/5

Tried for the first time today and was completely impressed! The waitress was very sweet and helpful, the atmosphere was nice and the food was AMAZING! Talked with the Chef and loved his passion for his delicious culinary creations. Cannot wait to go back and try more of the menu! 100% HIGHLY RECOMMEND

Abby B.

1/5

I was excited to try this new restaurant, thought I’d give it some time to get established in town before I went in. The salads were served on plastic plates with white toasted bread that was plain with the tiniest bit of butter.… ehh. Ordered the chicken Marsala with pasta, the chicken seemed nothing more than heated up Tyson chicken breast from a freezer. The mushrooms for the sauce tasted like they came from a can. The pizza was meh, ingredients all seem very cheap. Also paid $13 for the lemon spritzer which I thought was a bit extreme for what it was. All in all, I was expecting much better from this place. Definitely not worth $70…

Jessica D.

5/5

We had an Amazing dinner at Eatly tonight, the food was so good I forgot to snap a photo so I stole one from their page. This dish has amazing flavor and was one of the best meals I have ever eaten. If you have not been up to see their new Urbana restaurant do yourselves a favor and check them out, from the food, ambiance, and staff you won’t be disappointed.

Ray R.

5/5

Went to have lunch. Staff very friendly, great service. Food was spectacular! Salad with pesto ranch 👍👍 . Veal and chicken dishes were delicious! Definitely will return!

Jody S.

5/5

Ate here for the first time today and it definitely will not be the last. The lasagna soup was delicious, the veal parmesan and the dessert that I got were amazing. The waiter was excellent. Definitely a place everyone should try!

scott F.

5/5

If anyone needs a wonderful place to eat 20 minutes away in Springfield is a Hidden Gem called Eatly. We did Sunday brunch and they had $20 per person brunch. Choice of 5 differ meals with drinks
We tried the the double delicious biscuit sandwiches, a black and bleu panini with salad and zucchini fries , and finally the best homemade lasagna salad and garlic bread

We all loved the experience and meals.

Owner is doing this as a ministry to serve his aging parents and a tribute to his Sicilian heritage.

Eatly
601 N Fountsin Ave
Springfield Ohio 45504

Amanda

2/5

We were in the area and decided to try this place. Service was friendly enough but the food and ambiance were what tanked my review. This place is trying to be a lot more upscale than it actually is. We were sat in the back room with poor lighting and shawty patches on the wall. The pricing is insane for what you get as well. I ordered the big ragu which was described on the menu as "our red sauce and spaghetti, topped with Italian sausage and meatballs" this plate was 90% sauce (tasted like ragu from a jar) with tiny pieces of meat in it. There weren't any whole meatballs or Italian sausages, nor were there even any distinguishable pieces present on my plate. My plate also had no spaghetti and only one what appeared to be a cheese stuffed ravioli. The vegetable beef soup was okay, but I don't know how you can call that piece of borderline over toasted butter bread a piece of garlic bread.

PS your bathroom stalls are smaller than anything I've ever witnessed. Couldn't even tuck my shirt back in our turn around to flush the toilet without opening the stall door.