Dairy Isle - Toronto, Ohio

Dairy Isle: A Toronto, OH Ice Cream Institution

Dairy Isle, located at Address: Toronto, OH 43964, is a beloved ice cream shop that has been a staple in the Toronto community for generations. With a long-standing reputation for serving high-quality, delicious ice cream, this local favorite has earned a 4.5/5 star rating on Google My Business based on 159 reviews.

Specializing in a wide variety of frozen treats, Dairy Isle is known for its mouthwatering selection of ice cream flavors, including classic favorites and unique, rotating specials. The shop's signature peanut butter shakes are a must-try for any visitor, consistently drawing rave reviews from customers young and old.

In addition to its exceptional ice cream, Dairy Isle has made a commitment to providing a convenient and accessible dining experience for its patrons. The shop accepts debit cards, NFC mobile payments, and credit cards, making it easy for customers to enjoy their treats without hassle.

With its cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and unbeatable selection of ice cream, Dairy Isle has become a cherished part of the Toronto community. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, this local gem is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a truly memorable ice cream experience.

Phone: 405373211

👍 Reviews of Dairy Isle

Roy

4/5

I have been going to this place since I was a child.... This is a staple for Toronto.. peanut butter shakes are a must. I recommend this place to anybody who visits Toronto

Elizabeth M. (.

5/5

Just moved here from SC, and this place is officially my fave ice cream around. Good service, and the cookie dough ice cream hit all the right areas. Big gobs of cookie dough, unlike some that have small bits here and there, plus lots of chocolate chips. Makes this pregnant woman very happy 😂 it was also the only place around we found a dairy free option for our lactose intolerant toddler. Even if it’s just one flavor, I appreciate it being an option, and my husband said it tasted really good too! (Blueberry pancake I believe it was) pricing was also very good, especially for the amount you get.

Ami S.

5/5

Great ice cream and good food ! The customer service is always good. Quick service too. I love bringing my kids here for a quick treat on a hot day.

Shaun S.

5/5

Absolutely Delicious!! The Ice Cream & Milkshakes Here Are Excellent.. And The Staff Of Employees Is Wonderful. A Must-Stop If In The Area.. So Good. 👍

Tonya W.

5/5

Love their pistachio ice cream. Only place I can find it. Yum yum 😋

George I.

5/5

Consistently excellent! My wife and I frequently go here for ice cream, soft serve, milkshakes, etc. My typical favorites are a banana milkshake and a black raspberry milkshake. I highly recommend.

Jon L.

5/5

On a recent visit to Toronto, we went to Dairy Isle every single day of our 3-day trip. All three days we got ice cream and on our final day we also got food. They have a great selection of ice cream flavors, and their food is very good compared to what you would typically expect at an ice cream shop. I had the crispy chicken sandwich, my kids had chicken tenders and cheeseburgers, and my wife had the fried zucchini and hot pepper cheese balls. It was all very, very good. The service is a little slow, but this was possibly due to the fact that there was only one person working when we went the third time though there were 2-3 working at other times.

Heather L.

5/5

Feeling snacky hit the Isle. Just an old time side of the road Ice cream stand that serves just a bit more then ice cream. Gotta try the fried zucchini!!