Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli - Algonquin, Illinois

Ralph A.

Corey's in Algonquin is the best Bagel place I have ever been to. This is a true New York style Bagel the is not only made in house but also boiled and then baked. This is a diamond in the rough that you have to visit for one of the best Bagels and sandwiches you will ever experience.

Jenna

Absolutely wonderful modern bagel place! I was quickly served, and Corey (who took my order) was very upbeat and friendly. The workers who put my bagel together were hardworking and accurate. I got a blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese, which was very tasty, though they’re very generous with their cream cheese. I will come back to try their sandwiches! 🙂

Ian P.

We ordered two Honey Maple Turkey Sandwiches for carry out. They weren’t ready by the time the email stated, but the worker made them really fast when I got there. He apologized and it was only a few minutes wait. The sandwiches were big with plenty of meat on them with very fresh ingredients. I requested my bagel toasted, but I don’t think it was. We got coleslaw and pasta salad as sides and liked them too. And that pickle! Man, that’s the largest pickle slice/spear I have ever seen. Overall, good quality food!

Ross C.

I lived in NYC for years, so of course I’ve been wanting to check this spot out. Holy NYC, very on point and delicious. Great work Corey and the staff ♥️. I ordered my favorite, lox over chive cream cheese on a pumpernickel bagel.

Deanna H.

Corey’s was excellent! We decided on 12 bagels, a bunch of different flavors of in-house cream cheese, and two coffees. I love that how veggie and chive cream cheeses were made. Whenever I get a pre-made cream cheese, it’s fine. But the ones from Corey’s had such a healthy amount of veggies in them. The bagels were divine; We ended up making our own breakfast sandwiches the next day and they were still perfect!

The staff were kind and very welcoming. It seemed like they had a good sense of camaraderie with one another which often makes a space more welcoming. We will definitely be back.

Rogelio A.

Bagels just perfect!!!! We order plain bagel with honey walnut cream cheese plus a medium coffee, the perfect combination. The owner is just full of appreciation of the people coming in, employees atmosphere was incredible. Definitely will come back to try another breakfast bagels.

Fred L.

We loved our visit. Ate our food too fastro take pics . Wife and I ordered sandwiches and they were delicious. A bit pricey but...for high quality bagels, we will take it. Love that they have chicken deli as an option...Thank you!

Rachel M.

You guys!! This place is SO GOOD and so much fun! Brand new to the area, opened two weeks ago, I stumbled upon them randomly and was drawn in by the hot pink sign!

I'm in my "I need good bagels" era, and this place did not disappoint! Walking in, the place is STEAMY! they are hauling ass making the best damn bagels around. Get a breakfast Sando (build your own and don't forget the homemade delish cream cheese)! They have bagel lunch sammies and snacks. It's a great time!

Bought myself a half dozen of bagels to take home (plus the delish cream cheese!) and while grabbing my order, the lovely gentleman behind the counter asked me if these bagels I was taking home would be eaten in 2 days. Turns out, this place doesn't use preservatives and if you don't freeze or pop them in the fridge, they'll get hard. So eat them up or save them for later! I appreciate the note for the team there!

Go pop by to check them out!

Jenny M.

Carlos greeted us as soon as we walked in with a friendly face. It was our first time here and he took the time to go over the menu with us and gave some recommendations based on their most popular items. The service was impeccable and I would come back solely because of that. The bagels themselves were delicious. The cream cheese was amazing. I like how they have the option to build your own bagel. Will definitely be coming back.

Ralph A.

Corey's in Algonquin is the best Bagel place I have ever been to. This is a true New York style Bagel the is not only made in house but also boiled and then baked. This is a diamond in the rough that you have to visit for one of the best Bagels and sandwiches you will ever experience.

Jenna

Absolutely wonderful modern bagel place! I was quickly served, and Corey (who took my order) was very upbeat and friendly. The workers who put my bagel together were hardworking and accurate. I got a blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese, which was very tasty, though they’re very generous with their cream cheese. I will come back to try their sandwiches! 🙂

Ross C.

I lived in NYC for years, so of course I’ve been wanting to check this spot out. Holy NYC, very on point and delicious. Great work Corey and the staff ♥️. I ordered my favorite, lox over chive cream cheese on a pumpernickel bagel.

Bese O.

I’ve been wanting to stop in and try this place out since it opened and today I finally stopped in. As soon as I walked in Carlos greeted me with so much energy. Carlos seems like a great person to have working up front with the customers. I ordered a poppy seed bagel with chive cream cheese and took it to go. The bagel was good….but the real star of the show was the chive cream cheese!!! That was quite possibly the best chive cream cheese I’ve ever had in my life. A++++ I’ll definitely be back, I want to try the nova lox next and grab some chive cream cheese to go lol