Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More - New Philadelphia, Ohio

Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More: A Delightful Dining Experience

Located at 1816 E High Ave, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, United States, Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More is a renowned dining establishment that offers a delightful array of culinary delights. With a phone number of 3303651466 and a website at maggoosppm.com, Maggoo's has become a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Savory Specialties

Specializing in both pizza and Italian cuisine, Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More offers an extensive menu that caters to a wide range of palates. From classic pasta dishes to mouth-watering pizzas, there is something for everyone at this delightful eatery.

Other Points of Interest

• Outdoor seating
• Kerbside pickup
• No-contact delivery
• Delivery
• Takeaway
• Dine-in
• Fast service
• Great beer selection
• Great cocktails
• Great dessert
• Great wine list
• Dinner
• Solo dining
• Wheelchair-accessible car park
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance
• Wheelchair-accessible seating
• Wheelchair-accessible toilet
• Alcohol
• Beer
• Cocktails
• Coffee
• Comfort food
• Healthy options
• Quick bite
• Small plates
• Spirits
• Wine
• Catering
• Dessert
• Seating
• Bar on site
• Toilet
• Wi-Fi
• Casual
• Cosy
• Quiet
• Trendy
• Family friendly
• Groups
• Tourists
• University students
• Accepts reservations
• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments
• Good for kids
• High chairs
• Kids' menu
• Free of charge street parking
• Free parking lot
• Parking

Opinions and Reviews

This esteemed establishment boasts an impressive 497 reviews on Google My Business, with an average rating of 4.4/5. Customers consistently praise the restaurant for its excellent service, delicious food, and welcoming atmosphere.

One reviewer, for instance, shared their experience dining at Maggoo's: 'Arrived at 5 on a Saturday with reservations for 4. Servers name was Stevi. One order of Chicken Parmesan, one order of ham with scalloped potatoes and 2 orders of Larry's Big Bad Sampler that included salad, pizza and spaghetti. Diet coke, lemonade and ice water to drink. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed the salads. The pizza was good but not necessarily the best. The spaghetti was good but nothing outstanding. Could have put a bit more spice in the sauce. Key lime pie, tropical carrot cake, molten lava cake with ice cream and sopapila cheese cake for dessert. All dessert items were very good.'

👍 Reviews of Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More

Ricky M.

4/5

Arrived at 5 on a Saturday with reservations for 4. Servers name was Stevi. One order of Chicken Parmesan,one order of ham with scalloped potatoes and 2 orders of Larry's Big Bad Sampler that included salad, pizza and spaghetti. Diet coke,lemonade and ice water to drink. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed the salads. The pizza was good but not necessarily the best.The spaghetti was good but nothing outstanding. Could have put a bit more spice in the sauce.Key lime pie,tropical carrot cake, molten lava cake with ice cream and sopapila cheese cake for dessert. All dessert items were very good...

Tom B.

5/5

Great food,friendly service, and a pleasant atmosphere. Good selections of food with daily specials. The Big Daddy salad is awesome, and the stuffed Hungarian peppers are really good as well. Prices are reasonable, and portions are ample.

Sarah C.

5/5

Sitting at the bar overlooking the airport is my favorite place in Magoo's. The bartenders are fantastic and personable, very accommodating. I go back just for them. And the salad.

Michael K.

5/5

The pizza is absolutely delicious. I’ve been trying pizza places in New Philadelphia and Dover over the last few weeks. My wife is a big pizza fan. ( good or bad she doesn’t care as long as it’s pizza lol. But I personally only enjoy pizza that’s done right. Fresh toppings, not overly greasy, crisp on the bottom but still soft and airy and most importantly a crust as tasty as the rest of the pizza. Magoos pizza checked all those boxes. I’ve tried about 10 mom and pop pizza places in the last 2 -3 weeks and they have been by far the best. I’ll be ordering again and soon. I got the 16x16 pizza thin crust. Heather (The employee who took my order) said it’s what they’re known for. Although for a thin crust the pizza was still fluffy. Honestly it was just perfect . No other words would do to describe it. My wife and 2 sons also agreed with me. I got my order to go but The staff was very friendly. Heather took my order and I believe she’s the one who helped me when I got there. She was very nice. Thanks for the awesome dinner and customer service. Change nothing 👍🏼

Dan C.

5/5

Still love this place. I try different meals each time. Never disappointed. However, staying with the lava cake and a slice of Key lime to go for dessert.

Rhoda L.

5/5

Visited Maggoos for the first time. Their house salad dressing is amazing! Great atmosphere and quick service.

Rod M.

5/5

Went there and got the ravioli asked to have the half meat and half cheese. Was told the ravioli is pre portioned and not able to split, which was fine, but when it came out, they managed to split it anyway. That type of customer service is great

Lu A. Y.

4/5

We sat out in the patio, and though it gets noisy at times with all the planes starting up their engines, it's pretty neat to get to eat and watch planes come and go. The food is good also.