Gem City Pizza - Toronto, Ohio

Gem City Pizza

Gem City Pizza is a highly-rated pizza restaurant located at 901 Franklin St, Toronto, OH 43964. With a rich history of being veteran-owned, this establishment has gained a strong following among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant offers a variety of dining options, including outdoor seating, curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeout, dine-in, and onsite services.

In addition to its excellent pizza, Gem City Pizza is known for its welcoming atmosphere, making it a popular spot for sports fans, dinner gatherings, solo diners, and families. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, providing easy access for everyone. They also offer a range of comfort food, late-night food, quick bites, and small plates, catering to diverse tastes and preferences. Vegetarian options are available, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Gem City Pizza also provides catering services, perfect for special events and occasions. The restaurant offers counter service, with ample seating, a restroom, and a cozy, trendy ambiance. It's a favorite among college students, families, groups, and tourists, and is known to be LGBTQ+ friendly. Reservations are accepted, and the restaurant accepts various payment methods, including checks, credit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Located in Toronto, OH, Gem City Pizza is easily accessible by car, with free parking available in a lot and on the street. Dogs are also welcome to join their owners outside, making it a great spot for pet owners.

With an impressive average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars based on 103 reviews on Google My Business, it's clear that Gem City Pizza is a highly-regarded establishment in the area. Whether you're in the mood for a delicious pizza, a casual dinner with friends, or a family meal, Gem City Pizza offers a welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service to make your experience unforgettable.

👍 Reviews of Gem City Pizza

Troy B.

2/5

The pizza is good when it's made right. Unfortunately the last several times I've ordered it's been messed up in one way or another. Like tonight I ordered a tray 1/2 spicy and the other 1/2 spicy and sweet. I went over it again with the lady on the phone just to make sure they understood. Pizza gets here and I get a tray that's all sweet and half spicy. I understand mistakes happen but it seems to be a constant with this place.

Tru A.

5/5

I can't personally speak for the atmosphere, but if it's anything like their delivery service, then I'm sure it's on point. This evening I ordered a Buffalo chicken pizza and a Philly steak with just meat and cheese. There was a mix-up and I ended up with a BBQ chicken pizza, and a Philly steak with all the usual fixings(mushrooms, peppers, onions). As soon as I realized the mistake, I called them up and they exchanged the order within the hour. The Buffalo chicken pizza and sandwich I ended up with in the end were absolutely delicious and they were delivered with care. This is only my second time ordering since ownership has changed, but so far so good. Keep up the amazing work guys!
PS: I just hope the BBQ pizza and other sandwich found a good home in someone else's belly.

Shay Z.

5/5

I love love love Gem 💎 City Pizza! It's the best Pizza in Toronto. I wish they were open every day bc there's no where else I'll get pizza from again. Thank you so much for making AMAZING PIZZA 🍕 ❤️

misty P.

5/5

Im very picky on sauce and this pizza was amazing. They are also very nice and friendly. Price was good.

Ed Y.

5/5

We liked their Pizza when the original owners had it & still like it with the new owners!! Very good pizza, wish they were heavier on the cheese, but that's kinda a personal preference of how I like my pizza so not gonna fault them for that. Although we've always liked their Pizza, we think where they really shine is their other items, some unique that you can't get anywhere else like the Meatball Dumplings, specialty pizzas & amazing Calzones!! If you are visiting Toronto or just stopping by on your way to another destination, you must stop in and get some grub from Gem City Pizza........ You won't be disappointed!! "Hot Tip: Try the Swagger Sauce"

Wesley C.

5/5

If you are looking for local pizza with a great owner, this is your place!

Steelz M.

3/5

Pizza only, last week not cooked enough. The week before as if your chewing glass. Just ok

Buster B.

5/5

Phil, his staff, and food are top notch. Highly recommend!