Nautilus - Milford, Connecticut

Lora

First, awesome Pizza! Tasted first at Pizza and Brew Fest in Bridgeport 2024. We voted as #1, which they had received that honor in 2023. Not realizing they were just down the street with a friendly, happy local, neighborhood bar, we now frequent often. The owner goes out of her way to provide fun for all. Hidden local gem, great food, great drinks!!

JV F.

This is the type of place you hope to walk into when you try a new spot. Killer New Haven style pizza, staff that’s on the ball with service/portions and considerable seating for a smaller establishment. The crowd is diverse and friendly considering it’s CT. Always have a good time here. And it’s got a sea/coastal vibe with an actual nice fish tank.

Krystal D.

This place is an absolute gem and my go to! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a warm and welcoming staff that makes you feel right at home. The menu is top-notch, with a great variety of delicious options that never disappoint. My favorite is their mashed potato pizza and sliders.

Their Espresso Martini is hands down one of the best around—perfectly balanced and smooth. And if you’re a beer lover, the Nauti Lager is a must-try—crisp, refreshing, and always served ice cold.

Whether you’re stopping by for a casual drink, a bite to eat, or a fun night out, this spot never misses. Highly recommend!

Ruth Z.

We recently bought a home in Milford and were looking for a local restaurant to have dinner. We saw on Google that Nautilus was having a soft opening, so we decided to give it a try. Very happy we did. From the moment you walk through the door, the experience is fantastic. We were greeted by Deb, who it turns out does the wine list/selection. She was friendly, knowledgeable about the wine, the area and the restaurant. Our server was helpful in helping us with our food selection. Everything we ordered was fresh, seasoned well and perfectly cooked. My steak was excellent as was my husbands tuna. If this was our experience at the soft opening I look forward to when they are open full throttle. We had the pleasure before we left of meeting Crystal, one of the owners. What a delight. She definitely has her finger on the pulse of what people are looking for, high-quality food at reasonable prices. Drinks atmosphere , food service all top notch. Highly recommend.

Lynn S.

What a fabulous addition to the Walnut beach area! I love the open bay doors letting the beach breeze in! The place is beautiful and tastefully decorated with a classy, beachy feel to it. The food: I had a watermelon cocktail from the menu. It was fresh and light, and not overly sweet. The calamari app was amazing - cooked perfectly. There was a hint of heat and the dipping sauce that came with it was a great compliment. The black sesame crusted tuna steak was delicious! It was cooked perfectly rare, and served with seasonal vegetables and garlic mashed potatoes and a wasabi drizzle. The portions are a good size and the prices are reasonable. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable, and the timing between courses was perfect. Shout out to our server Ilario, he was outstanding! There are so many items on their menu that sound amazing, we can't wait to come back and try their other offerings. I'm happy they're in my neighborhood, and wish them many years of success!

Manders

I had an amazing time at Nautilus in Milford this past Sunday with friends! Right from the start, we noticed how clean and well-kept the restaurant was—it’s one of those places where you can tell they take pride in every detail, from the decor to the spotless tables. It really added to the comfortable, laid-back vibe.

Now, let’s talk about Phil, the bartender—he’s the kind of guy who makes the night even better. Super funny and engaging, but not over-the-top, he knew how to keep the energy going without stealing the show. Plus, his drink-making skills are on point, and he had us laughing the whole time with his clever one-liners. Definitely a highlight of the night, but the real star was the food.

We ordered the pizza, and let me just say, it blew my mind. I’ve always been loyal to New Haven pizza, but this one? Wow. It was so good, I had a serious moment of pizza reflection. The crust was perfectly crisp, the toppings were fresh and perfectly balanced—it’s hands down the best pizza I’ve had in ages. Sorry, New Haven, you’ve been officially knocked off your pizza pedestal.

Overall, Nautilus is a fantastic spot—super clean, great food, and a friendly atmosphere that makes you feel at home. If you want an awesome night out with amazing pizza and great drinks, this is the place.

Mahmoud K.

First time I come here with the family; honestly we were disappointed! Pizza was burnt to a crisp, and the quality of the food wasn't that great. It was obvious no one in the kitchen knew what they were doing. I hope they hire a more experienced kitchen staff.

Service was good, waiter was very nice.

Molly L.

Tom the waiter was awesome!!! Love the vibe of the restaurant! It's so chill and warm of a setting. Drinks and their prices are great! Had the lobstaaahh roll and fried coconut shrimp. Delicious! Cant wait to come back